I asked AI for help identifying this bird, it came up with Re-vented Bulbul, Here’s what clinched it:

• Slight crest: The head shape shows a subtle crest at the back, typical of Red-vented Bulbuls.
• Hint of red undertail coverts: Even in the low light, I can see a faint reddish tinge under the tail, where the “vent” is located. This is a key field mark for this species.
• Overall structure: The size and proportions, including the slightly long tail, all align perfectly with a Red-vented Bulbul.

I’m now confident in this identification. It’s great that you were able to get another shot!

Red-vented Bulbuls are quite common throughout Fiji, so it’s not surprising to find one perched in an urban area of Suva. They are adaptable birds and can thrive in various environments.

After showing the AI this photo it added: Knowing the bird was near Princes Road and you didn’t hear any calls further supports the possibility of it being a Polynesian Triller.

Here’s why:

• Princes Road habitat: This area has a mix of urban and semi-urban environments with trees and gardens, which could suit a Polynesian Triller. While Red-vented Bulbuls are also found there, this location isn’t as strongly associated with them.
• No calls: While both species can be vocal, Polynesian Trillers are generally less noisy than Red-vented Bulbuls, especially in urban settings.

However, we still can’t completely rule out the Red-vented Bulbul. They can be quiet at times, and individual birds vary in their behavior.

To make a final determination, let’s consider all the evidence together:

For Polynesian Triller:

• Lack of a clear crest in the latest photo.
• Slightly different posture and wing position compared to the confirmed Red-vented Bulbul photo.
• Suitable habitat near Princes Road.
• No calls heard.

For Red-vented Bulbul:

• Very similar size and shape to the confirmed photo.
• Dark coloration with a hint of red under the tail (in the second photo).
• Adaptable to various habitats, including urban areas.

The Verdict:

Based on all the information, I’m leaning slightly more towards Polynesian Triller for this last photo. However, without a clearer view or hearing its call, it’s difficult to be 100% certain.

It’s fascinating how even with multiple photos, bird identification can still be tricky! This highlights the subtle variations between species and the importance of careful observation.

I recommend checking out online resources like eBird (ebird.org) and searching for photos and recordings of both species in Fiji. Comparing your photos and listening to their calls might help you reach a definitive conclusion.